Citrus owners’ settlement money on hold
Citrus owners’ settlement money on hold
TALLAHASSEE, Fla. (AP) – July 14, 2017 – Florida Gov. Rick Scott had the legal authority to veto money to pay residents for healthy citrus trees that the state cut down in an effort to eradicate citrus canker, but some state Supreme Court justices admonished him Thursday for doing so.
While the court threw out a petition filed by Broward and Lee County residents attempting to overturn Scott’s veto of a budget item to compensate them for lost trees, three of the seven justices expressed dismay that Scott took the action and that residents still haven’t been compensated more than a decade after their trees were cut down.
“These petitioners have the right to full compensation. The time has come for the State to pay up,” Justice Barbara Pariente wrote an opinion in which Justice Peggy Quince agreed. Both reluctantly agreed to dismiss the petition because the governor was within his rights.
Justice Fred Lewis disagreed with dismissing the petition and said it was “a sad day for Florida citizens.” He said they have a constitutional right to be compensated when government takes their property, and the court failed them for not overturning Scott’s veto.
“This is not a game and our citizens should not be toyed with as if a yo-yo, and yet that is exactly what this veto accomplishes. Now, with the opportunity to stop this ten-year-game of yo-yo, this Court abdicates its responsibility.”
Canker is a bacterial disease spread by wind that blemishes a tree’s fruit and can cause it to drop prematurely. In 2000, the state ordered the destruction of all citrus trees, even healthy ones, within 1,900 feet of an infected tree. More than 16 million trees were destroyed during a six-year-program, including 865,000 residential trees. For compensation, the state gave each homeowner a $100 Wal-Mart gift card for the first tree killed and $55 cash for each subsequent tree, but thousands complained their trees were worth much more. Homeowners filed class-action lawsuits against the state.
This year, the Legislature approved $37.4 million for the Broward and Lee county residents, whose lawsuits had already run their legal course. Scott vetoed the money, saying there was still pending litigation – a point that Pariente and Lewis called misinformed and disingenuous.
A spokesman for Scott said there are still unsettled lawsuits filed by residents elsewhere in Florida, and that’s why he vetoed the money.
“It is unfortunate what happened to these Floridians over a decade ago and Governor Scott sincerely understands their concern. Due to ongoing litigation, the $37.4 million in the budget was not approved. We are hopeful that all litigation regarding this issue will be completely resolved, allowing the issue to be addressed comprehensively across the state,” John Tupps wrote in an email.
Source: Florida Realtors
-
$425,000
Fb04 - Avenida Pescadora To S.bd
Courtesy of Premiere Plus Realty Company
2 BEDS2 BATHS881 SQFTShare this Property -
$384,500
Beach And Tennis Club
Courtesy of William Raveis Real Estate
1 BEDS1 BATHS508 SQFTShare this Property -
$3,299,000
Bonita Bay
Courtesy of Dellatore Real Estate Company
3 BEDS4 BATHS4512 SQFTShare this Property -
$850,000
Bn06 - North Bonita East Of Us41
Courtesy of EXP Realty, LLC
3 BEDS3 BATHS2950 SQFTShare this Property -
$1,250,000
Bn12 - East Of I-75 South Of Cit
Courtesy of John R. Wood Properties
4 BEDS3 BATHS3283 SQFTShare this Property -
$160,000
Clewiston
Courtesy of Dyess Real Estate
2 BEDS1 BATHS800 SQFTShare this Property -
$680,000
Charlotte Shores
Courtesy of Florida Resale Properties Inc
3 BEDS2 BATHS1819 SQFTShare this Property -
$2,400,000
The Colony At Pelican Landing
Courtesy of John R Wood Properties
3 BEDS4 BATHS4260 SQFTShare this Property -
$3,499,900
Bn01 - Bonita Beach
Courtesy of Downing-Frye Realty Inc
3 BEDS3 BATHS3355 SQFTShare this Property -
$850,000
Bn04 - Bonita Bay
Courtesy of John R. Wood Properties
2 BEDS3 BATHS2060 SQFTShare this Property -
$595,000
Bonita Fairways
Courtesy of EXP Realty LLC
3 BEDS3 BATHS1704 SQFTShare this Property -
$579,000
Worthington
Courtesy of Keller Williams Realty Fort Myers and the Islands
3 BEDS2 BATHS1744 SQFTShare this Property